---
title: "Magic alternatives"
description: "Magic alternatives placed side by side on staffing model, phone answering, coverage hours, countries and notice periods. Every entry is dated. Read more."
url: https://assistbpo.com/compare/magic-alternatives/
updated: 2026-09-19
publisher: AssistBPO (SS Support Network LLC)
language: en-US
---

# Magic alternatives

Alternatives

Magic alternatives fall into three camps: managed monthly providers such as Wing and Wishup, hour-bank services such as TaskBullet, and US-based agencies such as Time etc and Zirtual. AssistBPO sits apart with employed assistants who answer phones in four markets. Every entry below carries a published price or says none exists.

Updated September 2026 · Reviewed by [Nimra Khalid](https://assistbpo.com/team/nimra-khalid/)

- Checked on their own site
- Dated and sourced
- No ratings or rankings

## Overview

People who shop around after reading Magic's weekly plans usually want one of four things changed. Some want a monthly invoice instead of a four-week billing cycle. Some need hours to bank rather than expire, because the workload arrives in bursts. Some want a US-based assistant for client-facing calls and correspondence. Some need a person on the phones in UK, Canadian or Australian hours, which very few assistant firms staff. Magic remains a sensible pick for a founder who wants a dedicated person with no minimum term and an on-demand layer behind them, so nothing here is ranked and none of it is called best. The seven providers below are described from their own published pages or the 2026 industry roundups named in the sources, with the month each figure was checked. AssistBPO is first because this is our site.

## How does Magic compare with AssistBPO?

The same ten rows on every comparison page, so two providers can be read against each other without re-learning the layout.

| | AssistBPO | Magic | Source |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Billing rhythm | Monthly staffing plan per desk, agreed before the assistant starts | Weekly rate billed every four weeks | getmagic.com/pricing, Sep 2026 |
| Published price | Published rate card, plus a costed staffing plan within 1 business day | $270 a week for 20 hours; $540 a week for 40 hours | getmagic.com/pricing, Sep 2026 |
| Live phone answering | Front desk and reception are core desks, answered in your business name | Calling sits inside assistant tasks; a staffed reception line is not listed | getmagic.com, Sep 2026 |
| Markets and hours | US, UK, Canadian and Australian business hours, staffed by shift | 20 or 40 hours a week, with an on-demand layer on full-time plans | getmagic.com/pricing, Sep 2026 |
| Continuity | Named assistant, trained backup and a team lead who runs a weekly review | Dedicated assistant with pooled on-demand support behind it | getmagic.com, Sep 2026 |

Magic facts as published on the dates shown. The AssistBPO [rate card](https://assistbpo.com/pricing/) is published too, from $400 a month, and the staffing plan is what sets where on it you land. Spotted a change? [Tell us](https://assistbpo.com/contact/) and we update the row with a new date.

## Who should choose AssistBPO, and who should choose Magic?

### Choose AssistBPO if

- The role includes a phone line, not only an inbox and a calendar
- You want employed, background-checked staff with a substitute already briefed
- Your week runs across more than one of the US, UK, Canadian and Australian clocks

### Choose Magic if

- A published weekly figure and no minimum term matter more than phone duty
- Overflow tasks land at unpredictable hours and an on-demand pool suits that
- You want to start small and change the arrangement between billing cycles

## Which companies are the main Magic alternatives?

1. ### [AssistBPO](https://assistbpo.com/services/virtual-assistant/)
Dedicated virtual assistants, receptionists, support agents and back-office staff employed by SS Support Network LLC. Each engagement has a named assistant, a trained backup and a team lead who scores calls and runs a weekly review. Desks are scoped by function rather than sold as a bucket of tasks.
**Best for**
: Owners who want the phones, inbox and calendar handled by one accountable person
**Pricing as published**
: Published rate card, plus a costed staffing plan
**Source**
: assistbpo.com, Sep 2026
2. ### [Wing Assistant](https://wingassistant.com/)
Monthly subscription with a dedicated assistant, a customer success manager and a task app for assigning and tracking work. Positioned for founders and small teams who want predictable billing and simple scoping.
**Best for**
: Small teams that want one monthly figure for admin and research
**Pricing as published**
: From $499 a month (Report section 6 roundup, September 2026)
**Source**
: wingassistant.com and Report section 6, Sep 2026
3. ### [TaskBullet](https://www.taskbullet.com/)
Sells hours in buckets rather than as a weekly commitment. Hours roll over for 90 days, there is no contract, and an account manager sits on every bucket. Philippines-based by default with a US-based option.
**Best for**
: Workloads that arrive in bursts, where banked hours beat a fixed week
**Pricing as published**
: Starter 20 hours $210; Light 40 hours $325; Part-time 84 hours $599; Full-time 168 hours $1,099 (taskbullet.com, Sep 2026)
**Source**
: taskbullet.com packages, Sep 2026
4. ### [Time etc](https://www.timeetc.com/)
A network of experienced US-based freelance assistants sold in monthly hour bundles. Unused hours roll over, there is no setup fee, and you can add a second assistant or share one across a team.
**Best for**
: Buyers who want 10 to 60 hours a month of admin from a US-based assistant
**Pricing as published**
: $390 for 10 hours a month to $2,160 for 60 hours (timeetc.com/plans-and-pricing, Sep 2026)
**Source**
: timeetc.com, Sep 2026
5. ### [Zirtual](https://www.zirtual.com/)
US-based, college-educated dedicated assistants on monthly hour plans that several people in the same company can share. No setup fee, unused hours do not roll over, and plan changes take effect the following month.
**Best for**
: Founders who want a US-based assistant on a fixed monthly plan
**Pricing as published**
: From $549 a month per Report section 6; 2026 reviews list $599 for 12 hours to $1,699 for 45 hours (Sep 2026)
**Source**
: Report section 6 roundup and 2026 pricing reviews, Sep 2026
6. ### [Prialto](https://www.prialto.com/)
Team-delivered executive assistance: a primary assistant, a trained teammate as backup and an engagement manager who documents your processes. More than a million hours delivered, with a 90-day minimum per engagement.
**Best for**
: Executives and sales leaders who want backup engineered into the service
**Pricing as published**
: Not published on the pages checked (Report section 6 roundup, September 2026)
**Source**
: prialto.com and Report section 6, Sep 2026
7. ### [Wishup](https://www.wishup.co/)
Dedicated assistants marketed as the top 0.1 percent of applicants and trained on more than 120 AI tools. Wishup also publishes the annual industry report that many 2026 cost guides cite.
**Best for**
: Founders who want an AI-fluent assistant at a flat monthly figure
**Pricing as published**
: $1,299 a month (Report section 6 roundup, September 2026)
**Source**
: wishup.co and Report section 6, Sep 2026

## How does AssistBPO work?

A discovery call, then a named assistant proposed within 72 hours. That person works your hours inside your tools through your own user accounts, sends an end-of-day report, and is covered by a trained backup when they are off. A team lead runs a 20-minute weekly review with you and scores calls and tickets monthly. Assistants are employees of the group, never freelancers, and you never co-employ them. Plans start at $400 a month for 40 hours, at $10 an hour, and rates improve as you add assistants. Get a staffing plan within 1 business day.

## Keep comparing

- [Magic vs AssistBPO](https://assistbpo.com/compare/vs-magic/) The head-to-head table for Magic
- [Fancy Hands alternatives](https://assistbpo.com/compare/fancy-hands-alternatives/) Managed offshore provider
- [Staffify alternatives](https://assistbpo.com/compare/staffify-alternatives/) Managed offshore provider
- [Somewhere alternatives](https://assistbpo.com/compare/somewhere-alternatives/) Managed offshore provider
- [Oceans Talent alternatives](https://assistbpo.com/compare/oceans-talent-alternatives/) Managed offshore provider
- [All comparisons, by family](https://assistbpo.com/compare/) Including the rest of the managed offshore and staffing firms

## What this desk actually does

- [Dedicated virtual assistant services for the work that eats your day](https://assistbpo.com/services/virtual-assistant/) Service
- [Tickets resolved by agents who learn your product](https://assistbpo.com/services/customer-support-outsourcing/) Service
- [Executive & admin desk](https://assistbpo.com/services/desks/executive-admin/) The desk this sits on
- [What moves a staffing plan](https://assistbpo.com/pricing/) The rate card, and the six things that move a plan off it

## Frequently asked questions

### Is AssistBPO cheaper than Magic?

Plans depend on hours, desks and coverage. Get a staffing plan within 1 business day. Magic publishes $270 a week for 20 hours a week and $540 a week for 40 hours, billed every four weeks (getmagic.com/pricing, September 2026). Put that beside the AssistBPO plan for the same hours, then read what sits inside each figure. Phone duty, a trained backup and a team lead's weekly review are part of an AssistBPO desk rather than extras.

### Which Magic alternative is best for phones?

AssistBPO is the only provider on this list that staffs reception as a core desk, with assistants who answer, transfer and book in your business name. Wing, Wishup, TaskBullet, Time etc, Zirtual and Prialto concentrate on inbox, calendar, research and CRM work, and none of them lists a staffed answering service on the pages checked in September 2026. If calls are more than a quarter of the job, ask each shortlisted provider for a recorded sample and the QA process.

### Which of these alternatives publish their prices?

Time etc ($390 to $2,160 a month), TaskBullet ($210 to $1,099 per bucket), Wing (from $499 a month), Wishup ($1,299 a month) and Zirtual (from $549 a month) all publish figures, as does Magic itself. Prialto quotes after a call, and AssistBPO sends a staffing plan within one business day instead of a rate card. Every number here carries the page and month it was checked, so verify before you budget; providers change plans without notice.

### Do any of these cover UK, Canadian or Australian hours?

AssistBPO staffs all four markets in local business hours, with Australian Eastern shifts on request. Time etc operates in the US and the UK. Wing, Wishup, TaskBullet, Zirtual and Prialto are US-focused and may be able to match another time zone on request, so ask each one to commit to an exact shift in writing rather than accepting a general claim about global coverage. A shift written into the agreement is what you can hold someone to.

### Why is Magic not one of the alternatives listed?

Because the page exists to show the other options. Magic is a good fit for a founder who wants a dedicated assistant with no minimum term and an on-demand layer for overflow, and the head-to-head with AssistBPO lives on the AssistBPO vs Magic page. We do not rank providers, publish star ratings or quote reviews we cannot verify. Each entry is a short factual summary taken from the provider's own pages or the 2026 roundups in the sources.

## Sources

- [Magic pricing page (Sep 2026)](https://getmagic.com/pricing)
- [Time etc plans and pricing (Sep 2026)](https://www.timeetc.com/plans-and-pricing)
- [TaskBullet packages and pricing (Sep 2026)](https://www.taskbullet.com/pricing/)
- [Wishup, virtual assistant cost guide (2026)](https://www.wishup.co/blog/how-much-does-a-virtual-assistant-cost/)

Next step

## See how a dedicated assistant compares on your numbers

Tell us the hours, the desk and the tools. A named person replies within 1 business day with a staffing plan and a plain answer on whether we are the right fit, or who is.

[Get a staffing plan](https://assistbpo.com/get-a-staffing-plan/) [Book a 20-minute call](https://assistbpo.com/book-a-call/) Or call [+1-657-777-0006](tel:+16577770006) during US, UK or Australian business hours, or [hear our demo receptionist](https://assistbpo.com/demo-line/).

- A named assistant proposed within 72 hours
- Employed, screened and managed staff, never freelancers
- Your hours, your tools, your data

---

Source: https://assistbpo.com/compare/magic-alternatives/ · Contact: https://assistbpo.com/contact/ · Full site map for agents: https://assistbpo.com/llms.txt